Choosing the right mattress is crucial for achieving a good night’s sleep, and the best pillow top mattress can make all the difference. These luxurious beds combine plush comfort with essential support, catering to a wide range of sleep styles. With a deeper understanding of the options available, our team of Certified Sleep Science Coaches has reviewed over 600 mattresses and accessories over seven years, ensuring a well-curated selection for you1. After evaluating more than 25 different models, we’ve narrowed it down to the top 10 luxury mattresses of 2024, designed to score high in comfort, durability, and pressure relief2. Whether you prefer a softer surface for a cozy feel or need robust support for your back, this guide will help you find the perfect match that suits your needs and budget.
What is a Pillow Top Mattress?
A pillow top mattress features an extra layer of cushioning sewn onto its surface, creating a soft, inviting feel. This layer can be made from various materials like memory foam, latex, or fiberfill and typically measures 2 to 4 inches thick. The design aims to provide enhanced comfort while maintaining support through underlying coils. With a plush pillow top mattress, sleep enthusiasts can enjoy pressure relief and contouring properties, catering to back, side, and stomach sleepers.
Pillow top mattresses are designed to offer noticeable pillow top mattress benefits, including a luxurious appearance and feel reminiscent of high-end hotel beds. Many brands, like Saatva, offer customers extended sleep trials, ensuring they find the best pillow top mattress for their needs. This confidence in quality often results in satisfied customers who appreciate the plush comfort.
The Saatva Classic Mattress provides an impressive sleep trial of 365 nights, making it a popular choice among consumers. In contrast, other models like the Nolah Evolution offer a 120-night trial while maintaining features that ensure comfort34.
How to Choose the Right Pillow Top Mattress
Choosing the ideal pillow top mattress requires careful thought about various factors like firmness, materials, and your sleeping position. It’s essential to consider firmness levels, which can range from soft to firm. For example, the best pillow top mattress for side sleepers typically leans towards a softer option for optimal pressure relief, while back sleepers may benefit more from a medium firmness option for adequate support5.
When shopping, pay close attention to the construction of the mattress. Hybrid designs, like the Helix Midnight Luxe, combine a plush pillow top with supportive coils, making them a popular choice5. This particular mattress features zoned support and a cooling pillow top, perfect for those who sleep hot5. The WinkBed mattress offers multiple firmness options, including Softer and Luxury Firm, catering to a variety of preferences while also including robust edge support5.
Cooling properties are another critical aspect, especially for hotter sleepers. Gel-infused foams or breathable materials can enhance comfort by regulating temperature throughout the night. It’s wise to look for mattresses that come with sleep trials, such as the 100-night trial for Helix Midnight Luxe and the 120-night trial for WinkBed, allowing you to test before committing5.
To make an informed decision when you are ready to buy pillow top mattress, it’s crucial to weigh these variables. Finding the right balance between comfort, support, and cooling will lead to a more restful night’s sleep.
Top 10 Best Pillow Top Mattresses for 2023
The search for the perfect sleep solution often leads to exploring the top rated pillow top mattress options available in 2023. Among the top contenders, the Saatva Classic stands out with an impressive average customer rating of 4.8/5 and a Nerd Score of 4.3/56. Its multiple firmness options, including Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm, make it a versatile choice for different sleeping preferences. Moreover, the Saatva Classic offers a generous 365-night home trial alongside a lifetime warranty, ensuring buyers feel secure in their investment6.
Another strong candidate is the Helix Midnight Luxe, which boasts a Nerd Score of 3.8/5 and an average rating of 4.7/5 from users6. With its medium-firm feel rated 6/10, it addresses comfort needs while offering substantial support. Customers can benefit from a 15-year warranty, providing additional reassurance with their purchase6.
For those interested in budget-friendly options, the Allswell Supreme mattress, priced at $487, delivers satisfaction at a lower cost7. Reviews suggest a balance of quality and affordability that appeals to many sleep enthusiasts. Additionally, the DreamCloud Mattress continues to receive rave reviews, with customers praising its support and comfort8. Many express that using this mattress has significantly improved their sleep quality, reducing pain over time.
Other notable mentions include the Serta Perfect Sleeper Innerspring Mattress available for $899. With three variations and eight firmness levels to choose from, it accommodates various sleep preferences7. The Beautyrest Harmony Lux stands at a price of $1,599 and emphasizes cooling capabilities, making it a great option for hot sleepers7.
Lastly, luxury options like the Stearns & Foster Lux Estate mattress, available for $3,599, provide advanced support with three firmness levels for the pillow-top version7. This mattress symbolizes high-end comfort, catering to those seeking the best pillow top mattress for their sleep experience.
Mattress Construction Explained
Understanding the construction of a plush pillow top mattress reveals how its various layers work together to provide optimal comfort and support. Typically, these mattresses feature an additional layer of cushioning that is around two to four inches thick, enhancing the softness of the sleeping surface9. The top layer is often made from materials such as foam, latex, or even natural fillings like wool and silk, which are preferred in high-quality variants910.
At the core, pillow top mattresses generally include inner coils that deliver essential support. Hybrid designs that combine these coils with plush toppers provide the ultimate sleeping experience, balancing luxurious comfort with reliable back support. While open coil spring systems are more affordable, they tend to have a shorter lifespan compared to pocket spring systems, which are known for durability and better support9.
It’s important to note that pillow-top mattresses usually last between seven to ten years if properly maintained. Regular maintenance, such as rotating the mattress as recommended by the manufacturer, can extend its lifespan significantly9. One significant downside is the susceptibility to premature sagging, particularly in the pillow-top area, making it essential to choose materials wisely10. Often, mattresses with natural components, like wool or natural latex, offer a longer life than those made from synthetic foam.
The Importance of Mattress Size
Choosing the right mattress size is crucial for maximizing comfort and fostering better sleep quality. The available sizes, such as twin, full, queen, king, and California king, serve diverse sleeping needs and fit various room dimensions. A larger mattress, for instance, allows ample space for couples or restless sleepers, which helps reduce responsiveness to movement, ultimately contributing to a more restful night. Understanding your room’s dimensions alongside personal preferences will guide your selection in finding the best pillow top mattress that suits your lifestyle.
Low-profile mattresses are typically 8 inches or less thick, making them suitable for children and ideal for settings like bunk beds and trundle beds11. Slim mattresses, measuring between 8 to 10 inches thick, are perfect for adults who prefer lower height beds or children11. Standard mattresses, with a thickness of 10 to 12 inches, cater to most adults weighing between 130 and 230 pounds11. For sleepers over 230 pounds or side sleepers needing additional pressure relief, thick or deep mattresses ranging from 12 to 14 inches are recommended11. The extra thick or deep mattresses go beyond 14 inches and offer superior contouring and support11.
Understanding these dimensions enhances awareness of pillow top mattress benefits. Generally, pillow top mattresses provide a soft cradling effect thanks to their 2 to 4 inches thick pillow top section9. It’s also important to consider that pillow tops typically last between 7 to 10 years with proper care, alongside various materials that impact durability and comfort. Opting for a model that combines pocket springs with natural materials like wool or silk may promote longevity9.
Comparing Pillow Top Mattresses vs. Other Types
When comparing pillow top mattresses to other types, several key differences emerge. Pillow top mattresses usually feature an extra cushioning layer, providing a softer sleeping surface, which is especially valued by side sleepers who benefit from the added comfort for pressure points. In contrast, memory foam mattresses are noted for their ability to conform to the body’s shape, offering customized support and pressure relief, making them popular among those seeking contouring properties.
Innerspring mattresses stand out for their firm support and affordability, often priced under $500 for a queen size model, while pillow top mattresses typically start around $90012. Traditional mattresses are cheaper and easier to move, appealing to budget-conscious shoppers12. However, pillow top mattresses may begin to sag within six years, compared to the average lifespan of 8-10 years for traditional models, leading to concerns about their longevity13.
Interestingly, pillow top mattresses are heavier than traditional options, which can pose challenges when rearranging a room or changing bed linens13. Furthermore, traditional mattresses often lack modern sleep technology like cooling materials and pocketed coils, which can negatively impact comfort and sleep quality14. While pillow top mattresses provide additional cushioning, they may also retain heat more than innerspring models, making them less suitable for hot sleepers12.
Euro top mattresses, another alternative, offer better edge support, which can be beneficial for those who sit on the bed’s edge12. Each mattress type has its own unique features, making it essential for consumers to evaluate their individual sleep needs when choosing the best pillow top mattress or another variety that fits their lifestyle.
Common Concerns About Pillow Top Mattresses
Those considering a pillow top mattress often express several concerns. One significant issue is durability. At least 30% of pillow top mattress owners have reported sagging or compression within the first three years of use, compared to only 17% of non-pillow-top owners15. The plush surface that makes these mattresses so comfortable can also trap heat, leading to discomfort for hot sleepers16. It is important to note that pillow top mattresses are often 30% more expensive on average than their non-pillow-top counterparts15.
Edge support is another critical aspect. The unstructured edge of many pillow top models can result in reduced stability, making it feel less secure when sitting on the edge16. Furthermore, the permanently attached pillowtop layer typically has a short shelf life and is subject to sagging16. Consumers may find that once the pillowtop becomes indented, replacing the entire mattress is often necessary, despite the underlying spring support being in good condition16.
A viable alternative to a typical pillow top mattress is purchasing a separate mattress topper. This approach allows for better longevity; a 2-3″ deep topper can be added to a decent pocket-sprung mattress, which can be turned and rotated16. Investing in a handmade mattress enables users to rotate both the mattress and the topper, promoting even wear16. To extend the lifespan of the mattress and topper, using a mattress protector is highly recommended16.
Maintenance Tips for Your Pillow Top Mattress
Proper maintenance of your pillow top mattress is essential for prolonging its lifespan and ensuring optimal comfort. It is recommended to clean your mattress at least twice a year, and for allergy sufferers, cleaning every three to four months is advisable17. Regular vacuuming helps eliminate dust, dead skin cells, and allergens17. Spot cleaning any stains right away can prevent them from setting in18.
Flipping and rotating your pillow top mattress every three to six months is beneficial to distribute pressure evenly, thereby mitigating sagging or indentations17. Utilizing a mattress protector can safeguard against spills and dust mites while preserving the comfort and longevity of your mattress18. Essential supplies for cleaning include a vacuum, baking soda, and a mixture of water with dish soap, which can help tackle various stains18.
Recognizing signs such as sagging or indentations can indicate when it’s time for a replacement to maintain a supportive sleep surface19. When you decide to buy a pillow top mattress, understanding these maintenance tips will enable you to enjoy a better sleeping experience.
Customer Reviews and Insights
Customer feedback is invaluable when it comes to evaluating the best pillow top mattress. Many users emphasize the excellent comfort and support provided by models like the Saatva Classic Mattress, which has received high ratings from over 100 owners for its overall sleep quality20. This mattress, priced at $1,676 with a 20% discount, also offers a 365-day trial period, ensuring that customers have ample time to assess its performance20.
Moreover, the Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Cloud is praised for optimal comfort and support, receiving high ratings. Shoppers can currently take advantage of a 30% discount on this mattress, which includes a 90-day trial period20. Many reviews highlight the durability and adaptability of these mattresses to various sleeping styles, making them suitable for a wide range of users.
The Bear Elite Hybrid mattress stands out as a favorite, boasting perfect ratings for comfort and support. With a 35% discount and a 120-day trial, users are quite satisfied with the mattress’s performance20. Similarly, the Helix Dusk Luxe has been noted for its compatibility for couples, thanks to zoned coils that provide excellent ergonomic support.
Insights from consumers about the Allswell Luxe Hybrid reveal mixed feelings, with some users mentioning a lack of edge support, while others appreciate its price point of $387, making it the best mattress under $50020. As for the K-Class Firm Pillowtop mattress from Simmons, its features, such as the 3″ of Dynamic Response Memory Foam, have been appealing to those who prioritize comfort21.
Feedback about the Helix Midnight mattress illustrates its medium-firm feel and support due to individually wrapped coils, catering to a diverse array of sleepers, including those with specific pain concerns22. This variety in reviews highlights how different mattresses can meet individual requirements, assisting prospective buyers in finding their ideal pillow top mattress.
Where to Buy the Best Pillow Top Mattresses
Finding the right place to buy pillow top mattress options can significantly impact your overall satisfaction. Online retailers offer an extensive selection of pillow top mattresses, with approximately 73 products available on platforms like US Mattress, showcasing a variety of comfort levels to meet different needs23. Customers often benefit from competitive pricing and frequent sales, ensuring a chance to find an affordable pillow top mattress.
Local mattress stores provide a hands-on shopping experience, allowing customers to physically test the mattresses. This tactile approach helps in understanding comfort levels firsthand. Many brands like Saatva and Naturepedic extend generous trial periods, enhancing buyer confidence. For instance, Saatva Classic includes a 365-night trial and lifetime warranty, while Naturepedic Concerto offers a 100-night sleep trial and a 25-year warranty4.
Purchasing a pillow top mattress online usually comes with additional perks, such as extensive customer reviews and the convenience of home delivery. Shoppers should also consider factors like the type of mattress protector required to maintain their 120-night comfort guarantee, which brands often emphasize23. Retailers like Stearns & Foster and Helix offer trials of 90 to 100 nights, allowing you to ensure your choice is right for you4.
The Cost of Pillow Top Mattresses
The pillow top mattress price can vary notably depending on factors like brand and construction quality. For example, American Mattress offers pillow top mattresses ranging from $1,200.00 to $4,399.99, reflecting the differences in design and overall comfort levels available, including soft, medium, and firm options24. Consumers will find various sizes available, such as Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King, which also influences pricing24.
When searching for the best pillow top mattress, it’s crucial to consider not only the price but also the reputation of the manufacturer. Beautyrest, for instance, ranks as the country’s third-leading mattress brand, which can be a vital factor for many shoppers24. Understanding these elements can aid potential buyers in setting a budget without sacrificing the features they desire in a mattress.
Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Pillow Top Mattress
In summary, selecting the best pillow top mattress involves understanding individual sleep needs and preferences. With their unique construction that includes a support section and a top layer made from materials like memory foam or latex, pillow top mattresses cater to various sleeping positions, making them suitable for back, side, and stomach sleepers25. However, consumers should be aware of some drawbacks such as a reduced lifespan due to compression issues and the challenge of even wear due to their one-sided design26.
Exploring options like separate mattress toppers can enhance longevity, offering the ability to turn and rotate for maintenance26. Buyers are encouraged to consider price ranges and materials, as pillow top mattresses typically fall on the more expensive side compared to plush alternatives25. Understanding these factors empowers you to make an informed decision on the top rated pillow top mattress that aligns with your specific sleep requirements. For a more detailed exploration of the pros and cons of pillow top mattresses, feel free to check out this resource.
FAQ
Q: What are the benefits of a pillow top mattress?
A: A pillow top mattress offers added cushioning for enhanced comfort, pressure relief, and a plush feel that many sleepers find appealing. They are suitable for various sleep positions and often provide a luxurious experience similar to high-end hotel beds.
Q: How do I choose the best pillow top mattress for side sleepers?
A: Side sleepers typically benefit from softer pillow top mattresses that provide better pressure relief on the shoulders and hips. Look for models with a rating of medium to soft firmness, as they contour better to the body.
Q: Do pillow top mattresses retain heat?
A: Some pillow top mattresses can trap heat due to their plush materials. However, many modern designs incorporate cooling technologies, such as gel-infused memory foam or breathable fabrics, to help mitigate this issue for hot sleepers.
Q: Are pillow top mattresses durable?
A: Durability can vary among pillow top mattresses. Higher-quality options often come with better materials and construction, providing longer-lasting support. It’s essential to read reviews and warranty information to gauge durability.
Q: Where can I buy an affordable pillow top mattress?
A: Affordable pillow top mattresses can be found both online and in local mattress stores. Online retailers often have competitive pricing and promotional deals, while brick-and-mortar stores allow you to test mattresses in person.
Q: What is the price range for pillow top mattresses?
A: Pillow top mattresses range from a few hundred dollars for entry-level models to over ,000 for luxury options. Pricing depends on materials, brand reputation, and additional features, such as warranties.
Q: How do I maintain my pillow top mattress?
A: To maintain your pillow top mattress, regularly rotate it to prevent uneven wear, use a mattress protector to shield against stains and allergens, and follow cleaning instructions specific to the materials used.
Q: Can I find pillow top mattress reviews online?
A: Yes, many websites provide in-depth pillow top mattress reviews, assessing factors like comfort, support, durability, and performance feedback from users. These insights can guide your purchasing decision.
Q: How does a pillow top mattress compare to memory foam?
A: Pillow top mattresses generally offer a softer, more cushioned feel due to their additional layer. In contrast, memory foam mattresses contour closely to the body’s shape for pressure relief, which may feel different based on personal preference.
